A quick note before the comparison: the well-known “Icebreaker” app for remote team connection rebranded to Gatheround back in 2021 — the Icebreaker name and domain no longer point to an active, separately branded product, so we’re reviewing it under its current identity. That’s a better match than reaching for an unrelated tool that happens to share a name. With that settled, here’s how Donut, Gatheround, and Gather actually differ for building remote team culture in 2026.
At a Glance
| Tool | Core Format | Best For | Starting Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Donut | Slack/Teams-native pairing & recognition bot | Teams that live in Slack and want lightweight, automated 1:1 intros and shoutouts | Free tier available; Standard from $74/mo |
| Gatheround (formerly Icebreaker) | Scheduled video meetings with structured activities | Onboarding sessions, all-hands icebreakers, and dedicated bonding events | $60/mo (Premium), up to 50 participants |
| Gather | Persistent 2D virtual office space | Fully remote teams wanting an always-on “office” for casual encounters, not just scheduled events | $12/user/mo (Essential); custom Enterprise |
Short Verdict
These three solve overlapping but distinct problems. Donut is the lowest-friction option because it works inside Slack or Teams and runs itself — pairing people and surfacing shoutouts with no one needing to “go” anywhere. Gatheround is built for scheduled, structured bonding moments — onboarding cohorts, all-hands kickoffs, department socials — where someone deliberately plans an event with an agenda. Gather is the only one of the three built as a persistent space: a virtual office your team can drop into any time, which suits companies trying to recreate hallway run-ins rather than just scheduled events.
Donut: Automated Pairing and Recognition Inside Slack
Donut lives inside the tools your team already uses — primarily Slack, with Zoom, Microsoft Teams, and FigJam integrations — rather than asking anyone to open a new app. Its core mechanic is automated pairing: Donut’s “Intros” feature matches teammates for virtual or in-person meetups on a recurring schedule, which is specifically useful for distributed teams where people on different floors, offices, or time zones rarely cross paths organically. Beyond pairing, Donut runs “Watercooler” conversation prompts, “Celebrations” for milestones, and “Shoutouts,” a peer-recognition system with points and a redeemable rewards store. “Journeys” let you build automated message sequences for onboarding or training programs.
Pricing starts with a genuinely usable Free plan ($0/mo) covering one Slack channel each for Intros, Watercooler, and Celebrations, plus Google Calendar and Zoom integration. Standard starts at $74/month (billed annually) and adds multiple channels, gift-card rewards, and HRIS sync from 50+ platforms. Premium starts at $119/month (annual billing) and adds unlimited Shoutouts, unlimited Journeys, and prebuilt Journey templates. Both paid tiers scale further with headcount in Donut channels, and there’s a custom-quoted Enterprise tier aimed at companies over 500 employees. A 14-day free trial covers Standard and Premium.
Pros
- Runs natively inside Slack/Teams — no new app for employees to learn
- Genuinely useful free tier, not just a crippled trial
- Automated, recurring pairing solves the “we never talk to people on other teams” problem without manual scheduling
Cons
- No live, shared-space experience — everything happens asynchronously or in 1:1 pairings
- Paid tier pricing scales with people/channels in ways that aren’t fully transparent without talking to sales
- Less suited to big, single scheduled events than to ongoing background culture-building
Gatheround (Formerly Icebreaker): Structured Video Bonding Events
Gatheround is a scheduled-event platform: you pick a time, invite people, and run a video session built around pre-made agendas and interactive formats — Breakouts, Q&As, Polls, Quizzes, Flashcards, and a Photo Booth among them. It’s commonly used for new-hire onboarding cohorts, all-hands icebreakers, and recurring department socials where the point is a dedicated, facilitated block of time rather than an ambient connection. Hosts can record sessions, generate automatic event recaps, and export data afterward, which makes it easier to prove the program is actually running and to reuse what worked.
Pricing is published as a single Premium plan at $60/month, supporting up to 50 participants per event, unlimited meetings, access to hundreds of pre-built agendas, 10+ activity types, recording, recaps, and data export. There’s no separate free tier or lower-cost option listed, and no explicit enterprise tier breakdown on the public pricing page, so larger organizations should expect to confirm volume pricing directly with Gatheround.
Pros
- Hundreds of ready-made agendas remove the planning burden from whoever’s running the event
- Strong fit for onboarding cohorts and all-hands-style sessions, not just small-team socials
- Recording and recaps make it easy to measure whether events are actually landing
Cons
- Single published plan at $60/month with a 50-participant cap — no visible free tier
- Event-based by design, so it won’t replace the kind of ambient, everyday interaction Gather or Donut provide
- Rebrand from “Icebreaker” means older references to the product online may point to the wrong URL or name
Gather: A Persistent Virtual Office, Not Just an Event
Gather takes a different shape entirely: it’s a custom, always-available 2D virtual office your team can walk into and out of throughout the workday, rather than something you schedule for a one-hour event. People move an avatar around a shared map, and audio/video connects automatically based on proximity — the closest thing available to recreating hallway run-ins and desk-side chats for a fully distributed team. Beyond the ambient-presence angle, Gather includes unlimited audio/video calls, chat, meeting recording, AI-generated meeting notes and transcriptions, and calendar sync, positioning it as a daily-use tool rather than an occasional culture event.
Pricing is per-member rather than per-event: the Essential plan runs $12/month per member (with a 20% discount for annual billing) and includes every core feature. A Custom plan for larger teams adds custom onboarding, bigger/multiple office spaces, hybrid-work configurations, SSO, extended trials, and regional pricing — all behind a sales conversation. Every plan opens with a full-featured, no-credit-card 30-day free trial.
Pros
- Only one of the three built for everyday, ambient presence rather than scheduled events
- Per-member pricing is transparent and predictable at the Essential tier
- Generous 30-day trial with full features and no credit card required
Cons
- Requires actual adoption — a persistent virtual office only works if people choose to be “in” it during the day
- Per-member monthly cost adds up for large teams compared to Donut’s flat/tiered pricing
- Not built for structured, facilitated bonding activities the way Gatheround is
Bottom Line
Think about the shape of the interaction you’re trying to create, not just the budget. If you want background, automated connection with near-zero ongoing effort, start with Donut‘s free tier inside Slack. If you need a dedicated, facilitated session — onboarding a new cohort, running an all-hands icebreaker — Gatheround‘s event format and pre-built agendas do the planning for you. If your real goal is recreating the feel of a shared office for a fully remote team, Gather‘s persistent space is the only one of the three actually designed for that. Many teams end up running two of these together — Donut for ambient culture, plus either Gatheround for set-piece events or Gather for daily presence — rather than picking exactly one.
FAQ
What happened to the app called “Icebreaker”?
The remote-team bonding platform formerly called Icebreaker (icebreaker.video) rebranded to Gatheround in 2021. It’s the same company and product line under a new name, which is why this article reviews it as Gatheround.
Can Donut and Gather be used together?
Yes. They solve different problems — Donut automates pairing and recognition inside Slack, while Gather provides an always-on shared virtual space — and many distributed teams run both simultaneously.
Does Gatheround have a free plan?
Its public pricing page lists a single paid Premium plan at $60/month with no separate free tier, unlike Donut and Gather, which both offer free or trial entry points.
Which tool is best for onboarding new remote hires specifically?
Gatheround’s structured, pre-built agenda format is the most purpose-built for onboarding cohorts, though Donut’s “Journeys” automation can run alongside it for ongoing onboarding touchpoints.
