Retail media has become the fastest-growing corner of digital advertising, and the pitch is simple: put your ad in front of a shopper at the moment they’re already holding a cart. Walmart Connect, Instacart Ads, and Target Roundel are three of the biggest non-Amazon retail media networks, and all three now run self-serve, auction-based platforms rather than quoting flat media buys — meaning there’s no fixed “price” so much as a bidding mechanic to understand.
At a Glance
| Platform | Best for | Pricing model | Self-serve console |
| Walmart Connect | Brands selling on Walmart.com wanting onsite + offsite reach | CPC/CPM auction, no public rate card | Ad Center, tiered Small Business / Enterprise |
| Instacart Ads | CPG/grocery brands targeting grocery-delivery shoppers specifically | CPC auction, winner pays $0.01 above next-best bid | Instacart Ads platform, daily or lifetime budgets |
| Target Roundel | Brands wanting Target’s shopper data with second-price-auction pricing efficiency | Second-price CPC auction (since Feb 2025) | Roundel Media Studio, self-service |
Short Verdict
None of these three publish a rate card — like Amazon Ads, all three are real-time auctions where you set a maximum bid and the platform decides placement. What’s actually comparable is the auction mechanic and reach. Walmart Connect has the broadest format range (Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, Sponsored Video, Onsite Display, and offsite media for Enterprise advertisers) and the largest Walmart.com audience. Instacart Ads is the most tightly scoped to grocery/CPG intent — you’re bidding to reach someone actively filling a delivery cart. Target Roundel is the newest to formally adopt second-price auction pricing (effective February 2025), which both platforms and industry analysts argue reduces the “winner’s curse” of overpaying relative to the next-best bid.
What Each Platform Actually Does
Walmart Connect
Walmart Connect splits its offering into two tiers. Small Business advertisers get Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, Sponsored Video, and Onsite Display, managed through the self-serve Ad Center. Enterprise advertisers add Sponsored Search, Brand Shop and Shelf placements, offsite media (ads that run off Walmart.com but are targeted using Walmart shopper data), and in-store ads. Walmart markets the platform as open to “businesses of all sizes,” with AI-powered campaign features and closed-loop sales measurement tying ad exposure back to actual purchases. Walmart’s own 2022 shift to a related auction model reportedly cut CPCs by roughly 55% quarter-over-quarter while increasing click volume, according to industry reporting — an indication of how much auction-format changes alone can move effective price.
Instacart Ads
Instacart’s sponsored product ads run a cost-per-click auction: advertisers set a maximum CPC bid per ad group, and Instacart weighs that bid against conversion rate and other signals to decide placement — the winner typically pays just $0.01 above the next-best competing bid, not their full maximum bid. Budgets are set as either Lifetime (a total spend cap with a start date and optional end date) or Daily (spend averages the daily figure over time, can run up to double on high-traffic days, and is capped at roughly 30.4× the daily budget per month without a lifetime cap set). No published minimum budget is required to start a campaign.
Target Roundel
Target Roundel’s self-service platform, Roundel Media Studio, launched Target Product Ads as its first ad type and has been expanding format support since. The significant structural change: effective February 4, 2025, Roundel moved Target Product Ads from a first-price to a second-price auction, meaning the highest bidder wins placement but pays only one cent above the second-highest bid rather than their full bid. Industry commentary expects this to reduce inflated bidding and lower effective CPCs over time, following the same pattern seen when Walmart made a comparable shift.
Pricing Breakdown
| Platform | Auction type | What you pay | Minimum budget |
| Walmart Connect | Auction-based (exact mechanic not published per format) | Varies by format and competition; no public rate card | Not published |
| Instacart Ads | CPC auction weighted by bid + conversion signals | $0.01 above next-best competing bid | Not published; budgets set as daily or lifetime |
| Target Roundel | Second-price CPC auction (since Feb 2025) | One cent above the second-highest bid | Not published |
Pros and Cons
- Walmart Connect — Pros: broadest format range, including offsite media at the Enterprise tier; closed-loop sales measurement. Cons: Enterprise-tier formats and exact eligibility aren’t detailed on the public site; you’ll need to log into Ad Center or talk to a rep to see real bid ranges.
- Instacart Ads — Pros: transparent, documented second-price-style mechanic; flexible daily/lifetime budgeting with no stated minimum. Cons: narrower audience than Walmart or Target — it’s grocery-delivery intent only, not general retail.
- Target Roundel — Pros: newest and most explicitly documented move to second-price auction pricing, which should reduce overpaying relative to the next bid. Cons: platform and format set is less mature/broad than Walmart Connect’s; fewer independent studies on real-world CPC trends so far.
Who It’s a Good Fit For / Who Should Look Elsewhere
Good fit: Brands that already sell through Walmart.com, Instacart-partnered grocery retailers, or Target — retail media performs best when it reinforces purchase intent the shopper already has on that specific platform, not as a general brand-awareness channel.
Look elsewhere if: You don’t sell through any of these retailers’ marketplaces, or your budget is too small to run meaningful auction-based tests across multiple platforms at once — a single well-funded campaign on the retailer where you have the strongest existing sales will usually outperform spreading a small budget across all three.
Bottom Line
All three have moved toward (or already use) second-price-style auctions that cap what winners actually pay relative to the next bid, which is good news for advertisers nervous about overbidding. Walmart Connect offers the widest reach and format range; Instacart Ads is the sharpest tool for grocery/CPG purchase intent; Target Roundel is the newest to formalize fairer auction pricing and worth testing if your brand already has Target shelf presence.
FAQ
Do I have to sell on these retailers’ marketplaces to advertise?
Walmart Connect and Target Roundel are built around products sold through their respective marketplaces; Instacart Ads is built around products available through Instacart’s grocery-delivery partners. None of the three function as general-purpose ad networks independent of selling on that platform.
What is a second-price auction, and why does it matter?
In a second-price auction, the highest bidder wins the placement but pays only slightly more (commonly one cent) than the second-highest bid, rather than their own full bid. This discourages advertisers from inflating bids out of fear of losing by a hair, and both Instacart and Target Roundel document this as their current mechanic.
Is there a minimum budget to start advertising on any of these?
None of the three publish a stated minimum budget. Instacart lets advertisers set either a daily or lifetime budget with no documented floor; Walmart Connect and Target Roundel don’t publish a minimum either, though practical minimums may be enforced inside each platform’s ad console.
