At a Glance
| Tool | Best For | Starting Price | Free Plan? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Analytics 4 (GA4) | Sites that want deep, free analytics tied into Google Ads and Search Console | Free | Yes — the standard product is free |
| Plausible Analytics | Teams wanting the cheapest cookie-less option with multi-site/team plans | $9/month (Starter, lowest traffic tier) | No — 30-day free trial only |
| Fathom Analytics | Site owners wanting flat, predictable pricing and no cookie banner | $15/month (up to 100,000 monthly pageviews) | No — 7-day free trial only |
Short Verdict
GA4 is the only genuinely free option here and remains the default for sites already using Google Ads, but it collects data via cookies, which generally brings EU/UK cookie-consent obligations with it. Plausible and Fathom are both paid, cookie-less alternatives that the vendors say remove the need for a consent banner around their own tracking — Plausible is the cheaper entry point, while Fathom’s flat per-tier pricing bundles more sites at every level.
What Privacy-First Analytics Actually Means
“Privacy-friendly” or “privacy-first” analytics tools are built around a specific technical trade-off: instead of tracking individual visitors across sessions with cookies or persistent device identifiers, they count aggregate pageviews and events without personally identifying anyone. Plausible and Fathom both market themselves this way, and both claim this design means their own tracking script doesn’t require a cookie-consent banner. GA4, by contrast, is Google’s standard, full-featured analytics platform; it’s free and extremely capable, but it uses cookies (such as _ga) and other identifiers to build its reporting, which is why GDPR/ePrivacy guidance in the EU and UK generally treats it as something that needs user consent before those cookies are set.
Pricing Breakdown
| Tool | Plan | Price | What’s Included |
|---|---|---|---|
| GA4 | Standard GA4 | Free | Google Marketing Platform describes Google Analytics as free “to understand the customer journey and improve marketing ROI” |
| GA4 | Google Analytics 360 | Custom, quote-based | Enterprise tier; no public price listed on Google’s own marketing pages |
| Plausible | Starter | From $9/month (lowest traffic tier; 2 months free if billed annually) | 1 site, unlimited data retention, 30-day free trial |
| Plausible | Growth | From $14/month | Up to 3 sites and 3 team members |
| Plausible | Business | From $19/month | Up to 10 sites and 10 team members, plus funnels and ecommerce revenue attribution |
| Plausible | Enterprise | Custom | 10+ sites, SSO, priority support |
| Fathom | Entry tier | $15/month | Up to 100,000 monthly pageviews, 50+ sites included, 7-day free trial |
| Fathom | Mid tier | $25/month | Up to 200,000 monthly pageviews |
| Fathom | Higher tier | $45/month | Up to 500,000 monthly pageviews (Fathom’s pricing page notes additional higher tiers exist beyond these) |
Both Plausible and Fathom price by traffic volume, so cost scales up as your site grows — unlike GA4’s flat $0 price regardless of pageviews. Neither Plausible nor Fathom currently offers a permanent free plan; both substitute a time-limited trial instead (30 days and 7 days, respectively).
The Cookie-Consent Angle
This is the detail that matters most if you’re also managing a cookie-consent banner. Google’s own support documentation on Consent Mode states plainly that “Consent Mode does not provide a consent banner or widget” — it’s a signal-passing framework your consent-management tool feeds into, not a replacement for one. When a visitor declines analytics cookies under Consent Mode, GA4 skips storing cookies and relies on modeled, cookieless pings to estimate the gap instead. Plausible’s and Fathom’s own marketing pages, by contrast, state that their trackers use no cookies and no persistent identifiers, and both claim this removes the need for an “intrusive” consent banner specifically for their own analytics. Fathom’s FAQ goes further, stating it is “fully compliant with GDPR, CCPA, and other privacy regulations” — a vendor claim, not independent legal certification. Importantly, switching analytics tools only addresses analytics cookies: if your site also runs ad pixels, embeds, or other cookie-setting scripts, you’ll likely still need a cookie-consent banner covering those regardless of which analytics tool you choose.
Pros and Cons
Google Analytics 4
- Genuinely free for virtually any site size, with no pageview cap
- Deep, direct integration with Google Ads, Search Console, and BigQuery export
- Google’s modeling attempts to estimate data lost from users who decline cookie consent
- Uses cookies and device identifiers, which generally triggers cookie-consent requirements in the EU/UK and under laws like the CCPA
- Event-based reporting model has a steeper learning curve than a classic sessions dashboard
- Consent Mode is a signal framework only — Google explicitly says it doesn’t supply the consent banner itself
Plausible Analytics
- Vendor states its tracker uses no cookies and collects no personal data, which it says removes the need for a cookie banner for its own analytics
- Lowest entry price among the two paid options, with a 30-day free trial
- Open-source project, with a self-hostable Community Edition for teams that want to run it themselves (confirm feature/cost differences from the hosted product directly with Plausible)
- No permanent free plan — only a time-limited trial
- Reporting is intentionally shallower than GA4’s, by design, since it avoids extensive tracking
- Pricing scales with traffic, so a high-traffic site can cost meaningfully more than GA4’s $0
Fathom Analytics
- Vendor states no cookies are used and claims full GDPR/CCPA compliance, with an EU data-isolation option
- Flat per-tier pricing bundles 50+ sites at every level, useful for agencies managing several small sites
- Includes automatic bot filtering, saved views, an analytics API, and unlimited exports at the entry tier
- No permanent free plan — only a 7-day trial, and a card is required upfront
- Entry price ($15/month) is higher than Plausible’s ($9/month) at the lowest tier
- Like Plausible, lacks GA4’s granular user-journey and ad-platform integrations
Who It’s a Good Fit For
- GA4 — sites that want free analytics and already run Google Ads or lean on Search Console/BigQuery
- Plausible — teams wanting the lowest entry price among privacy-first tools, with Growth/Business tiers for small agencies managing several sites
- Fathom — businesses wanting flat, predictable billing tied purely to traffic volume, with many sites included at every tier
Who Should Look Elsewhere
- Sites with strict compliance deadlines should treat vendor “GDPR compliant” claims as a starting point, not a legal guarantee, and consult a privacy professional for their specific jurisdiction
- Businesses needing granular ecommerce funnels, cross-device IDs, and a free tier may find both Plausible and Fathom light on free options compared to GA4’s $0 price
- Very high-traffic sites should model Plausible’s and Fathom’s tier costs against actual pageview volume before switching, since both pricing models scale with traffic
Bottom Line
If budget is the only constraint, GA4 wins by default — it’s free regardless of traffic. If your priority is avoiding analytics cookies and simplifying part of your cookie-consent story, Plausible is the cheaper of the two paid alternatives at the entry tier, while Fathom’s flat, site-bundled pricing suits agencies running several smaller properties. Either way, don’t assume switching analytics tools lets you remove your cookie banner entirely — check what else on your site sets cookies first.
FAQ
Does switching to Plausible or Fathom let me remove my cookie banner entirely?
Not necessarily for your whole site. Both vendors state their own tracking uses no cookies, so their analytics scripts specifically don’t require consent, according to their own marketing pages. But if your site also runs ad pixels, embeds, or other cookie-setting tools, you likely still need a consent banner covering those — switching analytics providers mainly removes one category of tracking from what the banner has to disclose.
Is Google Analytics 4 really free?
Yes — standard GA4 is free, per Google Marketing Platform’s own description of Analytics as “free of charge.” Google Analytics 360, the enterprise tier with higher data limits and an SLA, is quote-based and not publicly priced.
Do Plausible and Fathom offer a free plan?
No. As of this review, both offer only time-limited free trials — 30 days for Plausible and 7 days for Fathom — rather than a permanent free tier.
Which is cheapest for a small blog or marketing site?
Between the two paid options, Plausible’s Starter tier (from $9/month at its lowest traffic tier) is less expensive than Fathom’s entry tier ($15/month for up to 100,000 monthly pageviews). GA4 remains free regardless of traffic volume on the standard tier.
Does Google’s Consent Mode replace a cookie-consent banner?
No. Google’s own support documentation states that “Consent Mode does not provide a consent banner or widget” — it’s a signal-passing framework that a separate consent-management platform or cookie banner feeds into.






